Get a quote

Working with agencies

How to choose an SEO agency you can trust

Agency websites tend to sound alike, so the real differences only appear when you start asking questions. These are the ones we would ask in your position.

Published 30 October 2026 · SEO Strategies

A row of doors with one open and glowing, illustrating choosing an SEO agency for UK businesses

To choose an SEO agency, ask each one what it would do first, who would do the work and how it earns links. Then compare the answers. A good agency will give reasons that are specific to your business, while a weak one will give you a pitch that could suit anyone.

You can do this without knowing much about SEO, because clear thinking is easy to spot in plain English. Before you speak to anyone, decide what you want more of, whether that means enquiries, online sales or bookings. That one decision will make every proposal easier to judge.

What does an SEO agency do?

An SEO agency finds out what is holding your site back, fixes the problems that matter most and tells you plainly what it has done. Most of the work falls into technical fixes, content and earning a reputation through links and mentions.

Imagine you run an accountancy practice in Durham with a slow, thin website. That firm needs better service pages and a stronger local presence, and a plan built around national digital PR would be poor value. The agency’s proposal should show that it has spotted this.

Questions to ask before you sign

What would you change first, and why?

Any agency worth hiring should have some thoughts after a short look at your site. Listen for a reason tied to your market, such as a competitor’s stronger location pages. A promise to “optimise your content” tells you very little.

Who will work on our account?

Ask who you will speak to each month and how much of the work is passed to freelancers or other companies. The person selling to you is not always the person doing the job. Outsourcing can be perfectly fine, provided the agency tells you about it openly.

Where do your links come from?

Ask for real examples of links the agency has earned, and for an explanation of how it earned them. Google’s spam policies treat buying links that pass ranking signals as a violation. If the answer is vague, or arrives as a monthly package of guaranteed placements, you should keep looking. Our page on link building explains what good work of this kind looks like.

What do you need from us?

SEO depends on sign-off, developer time and your knowledge of the business. An agency that says it needs nothing from you is probably not planning to change much.

Warning signs in a sales pitch

Guaranteed rankings are the clearest warning sign, because Google states that no one can guarantee a number one position. These are the signs we would treat with suspicion:

  • The agency claims a special relationship with Google or a priority route into its results.
  • Its methods are described as secret and cannot be explained in plain terms.
  • Reports focus on rankings for phrases that nobody searches for.
  • Links are sold by the dozen from sites it will not name.
  • Nobody asks about your customers, your margins or what you want from the work.

Google’s own advice on hiring an SEO makes a useful companion here. It suggests asking for examples of previous work and for the timescale in which you can expect results. It also suggests finding out whether the agency has experience in your industry and your country.

How much does an SEO agency cost?

The cost depends on the work involved, so it is more useful to compare what each fee buys than to chase an average. A national ecommerce site with thousands of pages needs far more time than a tradesperson covering one town. Most agencies charge a monthly retainer, while some offer one-off projects or hourly consulting.

To compare proposals fairly, ask each agency for a breakdown of the hours or work included each month. A cheap retainer spread across twenty activities may buy very little of each. If your budget is small, a one-off SEO audit or some consulting for your own team might give you more than a thin ongoing package.

Agency, freelancer or in-house?

An agency suits you if you need several skills and do not have the work to justify a full team. A good freelancer can offer senior attention and is often a strong fit for a focused project, though one person can only cover so much. An in-house hire makes sense when SEO is central to your business and there is enough work to fill a full-time role.

Plenty of businesses keep content in-house and bring in outside help for technical work and strategy. Be realistic about what your team has time for, as a plan that relies on writers you do not have will stall by the second month.

Does the agency need to be local?

A local agency is useful but not essential, since most SEO work happens remotely. Being nearby helps if you want to meet in person or if your market is strongly regional. For a business around Tyneside, an agency that knows Gateshead from Whitley Bay may write better location pages.

We are based in Newcastle and work across the UK, so we see both sides of this. If local searches matter most to you, ask each agency how it would approach local SEO for your area. The answer should mention real towns and real competitors.

Check what you will own if you leave

You should keep everything created for your business if the relationship ends. Your analytics and Search Console accounts should be set up in your name, with the agency given access as a user. The same applies to your Google Business Profile, and you should own any content written and paid for as part of the work.

Read the contract closely for the notice period and the minimum term. Ask what happens to any links or pages hosted on the agency’s own platforms if you stop paying.

Questions about hiring an SEO agency

How long should we give an agency before judging it?

Give it around six months before judging commercial results, as Google’s guidance suggests that improvements often take four months to a year. You can judge the quality of the communication and the work itself much sooner than that.

What should a monthly report include?

A useful report shows what was done, what changed and what is planned next, with figures for enquiries or sales from organic search. Rankings and traffic can sit alongside those figures, but they should not be the only measures you receive.

Should the agency have worked in our industry before?

Industry experience helps, particularly in regulated areas such as finance and healthcare, but it is not always essential. An agency that asks good questions about your customers can often learn your market quickly and bring useful ideas from other sectors.

Can we switch agencies partway through a campaign?

You can switch agencies, provided you hold your own accounts and have a record of the work done so far. Ask for a full handover first, including any redirects, disavow files and content plans, so that nothing gets lost.

Ready to ask us these questions yourself?

Get a free quote